Jules Evans
Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000

If you see Angie Buxton-King at work on the cancer wards at University College Hospital in Central London, she looks like any other medic: alert, down to earth, overworked. But her talents are different - she is a spiritual healer, one of a handful on the NHS payroll. But she hopes that, with new research and regulation of healing, there may soon be more like her.
Cancer patients at UCH are offered a range of complementary treatments as well as chemotherapy and radiotherapy. These are provided by a four-strong team led by Buxton-King: two healers (Angie and her husband Graham), a counsellor and a massage therapist.
Their services are in great demand, which is hardly surprising: statistics suggest that about 90 per cent of cancer patients avail themselves of some form of complementary medicine.
In a small room behind the team's office, a CD of relaxing music is playing. The patient lies on a couch while Buxton-King runs her hands over him or her to “channel the healing energy”. Many patients report feeling heat emanating from the hands, and a feeling of profound relaxation and peace. Each session lasts for 15 minutes.
So how did this all start? In the late 1990s Buxton-King's son, Sam, was fighting leukaemia. “He wasn't expected to live longer than three months,” she says, “so we looked at alternative ways of helping him, and during the three more years that he lived, it became obvious that his quality of life was improved by healing.”
Buxton-King wanted to help other NHS cancer patients, and first offered her services to Great Ormond Street hospital. They were sceptical, so she went to UCH, where she asked Dr Stephen Rowley, the clinical director of haematology, for a chance to prove the need for her services and was taken on for a trial month, one day a week.
“At the end of that time they were very interested,” says Buxton-King. “The whole ward benefited - staff as well as patients.”
She was taken on for two days a week, and eventually made manager of the complementary team. Four other healers also work at UCH, paid for by a charity that Angie and Graham set up.
Now the team is fully accepted as integral to the treatment on the cancer wards. Dr Maria Michelagnoli, a paediatric and adolescent consultant oncologist, says: “I was a sceptic at first, but you can't question the results. I'd be devastated if we lost these professionals now.”
Dr Rowley says: “I see experienced doctors call for the healer to help to support a child having a cannula put into a vein. Patients benefit in many ways.”
Other experts concur. Derryn Borley, the head of support services at Macmillan Cancer Support, says: “There is evidence that it improves patients' moods and can help with physical symptoms. It also helps people to go through chemotherapy.”
Spiritual healing may be hands-on, hands-off or conducted from a distance. Practitioners say that they are channelling energy from a higher source. It is distinct from faith healing, requiring no shared religion between healer and patient.
Some scientists believe that, if it works, it is the result of a “healing intention” in the healer's mind. This might also help to explain why praying for the sick can help them to recover, as some research has suggested it does. A study in Israel, for instance, published in 2001, looked at two groups of people with blood infections, one prayed for, the other not. It indicated that the prayed-for patients had shorter stays in hospital, stayed feverish for less time, and were more likely to survive.
Professor Edzard Ernst, of Exeter University, studied 110 patients with chronic pain, half of whom were treated by professional spiritual healers, the other half by actors pretending to be healers. “The results were staggering,” he wrote. “Several patients practically abandoned their wheelchairs. But there were no differences between the groups - if anything, the control patients fared slightly better. This suggests that spiritual healing is a strong placebo but not much more.”
Naturally, full-time healers dispute this. “I wanted to see if it was true so for a while I just practised on animals. I still saw positive results,” says Buxton-King.
Patients also believe that something “real” is happening. Dr Anil Wijetunge, an NHS tutor, became sick with bone marrow cancer in 2005 and received spiritual healing at UCH. “Something was going on with the energy,” he says. “The healers knew which part of me was suffering the most.”
To raise funds for more NHS healers, Buxton-King set up the Sam Buxton Sunflower Healing Trust, which held “Sunflower Jam” concerts in 2006 and 2007. The next concert is due to feature a re-formed Deep Purple.
Could the NHS provide more support? Baroness Finlay, a professor of palliative medicine at Cardiff University School of Medicine, says: “It's not enough to say that spiritual healing makes patients feel better. Having a haircut might as well, but that doesn't mean the NHS should pay for it. We need evidence that it works.”
Anecdotal evidence from former patients is in favour, but some healers accept that further proof will be required - which is partly why Buxton-King is carrying out a trial this year on reiki, a form of spiritual healing used in Japan, which will be funded by UCH.
Another hotly debated area is regulation. A government working group chaired by Professor Mike Pittilo recently recommended statutory regulation for Chinese medicine and acupuncture, and last month Professor Pittilo wrote in The Times: “There is honest recognition that the evidence base for many [complementary] therapies is thin but, given the public demand for treatment, this should be addressed alongside the introduction of statutory regulation, rather than as a prerequisite.”
Regulating spiritual healers would be quite a challenge. There are 15,000 at work in the UK, and several governing bodies. But, says Buxton-King, “it's the only way it's going to go forward”.
The 2008 Sunflower Jam is on Thursday, September 25, in London. For details go to www.thesunflowerjam.com
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
Special Offers now available
New Year in the USA!
.
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Research has been carried out regarding the placebo effect. I have seen papers from the Royal College of Surgeons on a research programme which tested stressed fungi in the hands of a healer, non-healer and a control sample. The healer achieved overwhelmingly positive results.
Jo Edwardes, Redhill,
I am a healer, practicing since 1997. I could help a lot of people using energy healing where other methods could not for them. Let me ask a question to all those who sound aganist it.. Have you ever tried to learn or experience it personally.. if yes how long didi you try...? Most can experience
Mathew Abraham, West Sussex, United Kingdom
I am am experienced healer. The effects of the healing energy I am able to channel are measurable. I have been trying for four years to get into a GP surgery, just to do a free demonstration of healing for them. To date I have had no success. I believe healing has much to offer the NHS patients.
Helen jameson, Cirencester, UK
I am currently researching ways to personally develop Spiritual Healing Techniques and help in the process of healing my wife who is battling against Small Cell Carcinoma in her left lung. A Parapsychologist by the name of Dean Radin has reseached the subject for decades.
Chuck Micallef, Newcastle-under-Lyme, U.K.
Thanks to John of Madrid for the link to genuine open-minded research. I am making a film (less than 20 mins) from footage taken at a Breast Cancer Charity Pamper Day. Several ladies provided very convincing evidence of how complementary therapies had helped them regain their quality of life.
Mahes, Chesterfield,
In answert to the reference that Reiki might be just a placebo effect, this study (among others) sheds some light on the matter...
http://www.courant.com/news/health/hc-healingtouch0728.artjul28,0,4379719.story
John, Madrid, Spain
Having been sceptical at first, I have now had many session of healing at the Harry Edwards sanctuary at Shere and can highly reccommend it.
I found it very beneficial to my needs.
Amanda, Surrey, UK
Rosemary: I have no idea what a 'reputable' spiritual healer is.
As I said in my reply to Jenny, relaxation is great, but just because it appears to 'work for you' does not mean it works.
Alan Henness, Glasgow,
In the hands of a reputable healer it can do nothing but good. Used alongside conventional medicine it is wonderful. I do not know how it works but I only know that it does and that it can make people feel so much better.
It is not mind over matter and you have to try it to really appreciate it.
Rosemary Roberts, Kent, UK
For all of you that doubt I would suggest you try one session even if for relaxation purposes only. Give it a go I think you may be suprised and you never know when it may be of benefit to you or your family in the future to help cope with whatever life throws your way.
Jenny Ward, Worcester, UK
We can no longer perscribe placebos in the uk, even though we are aware they frequently work, yet we hire these spiritual healers.
The NHS has much better things to spend its money on.
Convert them to a major religion instead, its less of a con than "healing energies" and at least its free.
AH, Belfast, Northern Ireland
Ingrid Collins: "Healers have equivalent standards to other health professionals"? What utter nonsense! As for these 'healing' methods, there is no quality evidence that they have any effect over placebo.
Alan Henness, Glasgow,
I really think your time would be better served campaigning for the NHS to treat Stroke patients which they dont.
You know, clot busting drugs things like that.
Mike, Berlin,
Healers have equivalent standards to other health professionals. Research by health scientists & quantum physicists on spiritual healing & subtle energy treatments has yielded significantly positive results, eg Prof Tiller (Stanford University), Prof Schwartz (University of Arizona) & Dr D Benor.
Ingrid Collins, London, United Kingdom
I find this interesting because I have worked on a hypothesis "By reducing the number of attempts to cannulate, you could reduce spreading MRSA in hospital. Even experienced doctor take 2-3 attempts, any reduction no matter how helps prevent infection. Check out Medifix in youtube
Dr Kadiyali M Srivatsa, Guildford, UK
Anecdotal 'evidence' does just not cut it, no matter how strongly held.
It's high time the NHS ditched nonsense such as spiritual 'healing'. It may be comforting; it may be relaxing; the placebo effect may also come into play. However, there is not one shred of reliable evidence that it works.
Alan Henness, Glasgow,
Sceptical? Evidence? Please read the article...
'You can't question the results.' 'Staff and patients benefit..'
'I'd be devastated if we lost these professionals now.'
'Their services are in great demand.'
Let there be trials. As many as possible.
Regulation? See Steve Sharpe above.
Jean Beith, London, england
Regulation for spiritual healers has been undertaken by the UK Healers (representing approximately 17,000 healers) for the last 6 years. UK Healers has in place standards of good practice, code of conduct, complaints and disciplinary procedure,etc.They also have the ear of Skills for Health Council
Steve Sharpe, Pinner, England
Could Professor Ernst explain how one can design a placebo when we have no idea of any of the possible underlying mechanisms involved in healing? Might not actors be such sympathetic individuals that they are excellent healers, unbeknownst to themselves? Understanding the placebo effect and indeed the effectiveness of treatments with currently unknown biological mechanisms is substantially more complex than Ernst suggests.
Professor George Lewith, Southampton, UK